Skip to Content Top

Understanding the Dewberry Trademark Case: Disgorgement of Profits and Calculating Damages


Understanding the Dewberry Trademark Case: Disgorgement of Profits and Calculating Damages

The Dewberry trademark case, currently under consideration by the Supreme Court, delves into pivotal issues surrounding trademark infringement, specifically addressing disgorgement of profits and the methodologies employed by courts to calculate damage awards. These aspects are critical not only for resolving the immediate dispute between Dewberry Consultants LLC and Dewberry Farm but also for establishing precedent in trademark law that impacts businesses nationwide.

Disgorgement of Profits: Core Issue on Appeal

At the heart of the Dewberry case is the contentious issue of disgorgement of profits, a legal remedy sought by Dewberry Farm against Dewberry Consultants LLC for alleged trademark infringement. Disgorgement of profits refers to the requirement for a defendant to surrender the profits it wrongfully gained through infringing activities, aiming to prevent unjust enrichment and compensate the trademark owner for losses suffered.

In this case, Dewberry Farm argued that Dewberry Consultants LLC unlawfully used the "Dewberry" trademark, causing consumer confusion and diluting the distinctiveness of their own brand associated with agricultural products. As a result, Dewberry Farm sought to reclaim the profits Dewberry Consultants LLC accrued from its engineering services under the disputed trademark.

Courts' Methodologies in Calculating Damage Awards

The calculation of damages in trademark infringement cases involves complex assessments aimed at fairly compensating the aggrieved party while deterring future infringements. Courts typically consider various factors to determine the amount of financial remedy, including:

1. Profits Made by the Infringing Party: Courts examine the revenues and profits directly attributable to the infringing activities. This analysis requires detailed financial disclosures and evidence demonstrating the link between the infringing use of the trademark and the financial gains realized by the defendant.

2. Calculating Reasonable Royalties: Alternatively, courts may calculate damages based on a reasonable royalty that the defendant would have paid to use the trademark lawfully. This approach estimates the economic value of the trademark use and aims to restore the rightful trademark owner to the position they would have been in had the infringement not occurred.

3. Consideration of Actual Damages: Beyond profits, courts may consider other forms of compensatory damages, such as actual losses suffered by the trademark owner due to the infringement. This could include harm to brand reputation, loss of market share, or expenses incurred to mitigate the effects of infringement.

Legal Precedents and Case-Specific Factors

In trademark disputes like Dewberry, courts also rely on legal precedents and case-specific factors to guide their decisions on damages:

1. Precedents: Courts consider prior rulings and legal standards concerning trademark infringement and disgorgement of profits. This helps ensure consistency in applying legal principles and promotes predictability in outcomes.

2. Consumer Confusion and Market Impact: The extent of consumer confusion caused by the trademark infringement and its impact on the market are crucial factors in assessing damages. Evidence demonstrating consumer perceptions and market behavior may influence the court's calculation of financial remedies.

3. Equitable Considerations: Courts also weigh equitable factors, such as the defendant's conduct and the degree of willfulness in the infringement. Willful misconduct may lead to enhanced damages, whereas innocent or inadvertent infringement might result in lesser penalties.

Implications for Business Owners and Legal Strategy

The outcome of the Dewberry case will likely set important precedents and impact how businesses approach trademark disputes and financial liability:

1. Risk Assessment and Compliance: Businesses should carefully assess trademark risks and ensure compliance with intellectual property laws to mitigate exposure to damages and legal liabilities.

2. Strategic Use of Trademarks: Clear understanding of trademark rights and enforcement strategies can help businesses protect their brands and leverage intellectual property as a competitive advantage.

3. Legal Guidance and Expertise: Engaging legal counsel with expertise in trademark law is essential for navigating complex disputes, understanding potential liabilities, and optimizing legal defenses.


In conclusion, the Dewberry trademark case highlights the multifaceted issues of disgorgement of profits and the methodologies employed by courts to calculate damages in trademark infringement cases. As the Supreme Court prepares to adjudicate on these critical matters, the decision will not only resolve the immediate dispute between Dewberry Consultants LLC and Dewberry Farm but also shape legal standards that govern trademark protection and enforcement nationwide. Businesses and stakeholders in intellectual property should closely monitor the case's developments and consider its potential implications for their trademark strategies and legal compliance efforts. By staying informed and proactive, businesses can navigate the evolving landscape of trademark law with clarity and strategic foresight, safeguarding their brands and maximizing their market potential.


Contact Us Today

Get Experience On Your side

Call (463) 287-6731 or fill out the form below to get started with a consultation.

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Acceptable Use Policy
  • We Research Thoroughly

    Detail-oriented, we leave no stone unturned in our pursuit of favorable outcomes for our clients--and often find information  you didn't know you needed.

  • Simplifying the Process

    We explain legal concepts in plain language, guide our clients through each step of the process, and handle the details so you can focus on what matters most to you.

  • Comprehensive Approach

    With holistic service from beginning to end, we stick with our clients through the lifetime of your assets, including litigation if necessary.

  • Responsive & Reachable

    We prioritize timely communcation; our team is responsive and accessible, and you'll never be left wondering where your case stands.